30 Prompts for Mining Customer Reviews into Copy
Stillwell Pet’s smart water fountain has 1,800 marketplace reviews averaging 4.3 stars, and nearly every five-star note mentions the same thing in different words: their cat finally started drinking more water. The copy team was still writing headlines from a features list while the best lines sat unread on page nine. The 30 prompts below walk the whole path, from clustering raw reviews to headlines, objection handlers and post-purchase emails. Paste real review text into each one; for the product page blocks that follow, see our product description workflow, and match the winning angle with the ad hook type picker.
Read the Reviews: Clustering and Ranking
Start here. You cannot write from 1,800 rows; you write from six themes and their best lines.
1. Cluster the whole review set into themes with counts.
Here are customer reviews for a Stillwell Pet smart water fountain. Group them into no more than six themes, give each theme a plain name, and state how many reviews fall in it. Quote the single best line for each. Do not invent reviews. Reviews: [paste].2. Rank themes by how much they drive five-star versus one-star ratings.
Using these themed reviews for the Stillwell Pet fountain, rank the themes by how often they appear in 5-star reviews versus 1-star reviews. Show a two-column count and flag any theme that flips from praise to complaint. Reviews: [paste].3. Pull the verbatim lines about cats drinking more water.
From these reviews, extract every sentence where the owner describes their cat or dog drinking more since buying the Stillwell Pet fountain. Return them as a list of direct quotes with the star rating next to each. Keep the wording exactly. Reviews: [paste].4. Find the most repeated exact phrase in the set.
Find the phrase that repeats most often across these Stillwell Pet fountain reviews, ignoring product words. List the top five repeated phrases with counts, then note which one reads best as a headline. Reviews: [paste].5. Separate the reason people bought from the praise after buying.
Split these reviews into two buckets: what pushed the buyer to purchase, and what they liked after using it. Give me five lines per bucket, quoted verbatim. This separates the hook from the proof. Reviews: [paste].Headlines and Ad Angles from Real Praise
The best headlines are already in the reviews. Your job is to cut them down, not invent them.
6. Ten benefit headlines built from five-star phrases.
Write ten headlines for the Stillwell Pet fountain, each built from a phrase real owners used. Keep every headline under 12 words, lead with the pet owner's outcome, and put the source quote in brackets after each. Quotes: [paste].7. Three cold-traffic ad angles, one per top theme.
Turn these three review themes into three ad angles for cold traffic on Facebook. For each: a one-line angle, the emotional driver, and a first sentence under 15 words. Avoid claims about health or curing illness. Themes: [paste].8. A headline aimed at owners with two or more cats.
Write five headline options for the Stillwell Pet fountain aimed at households with two or more cats. Reference the multi-cat use case and the reviews that mention it. Under 12 words each, no exclamation marks. Reviews: [paste].9. A pain-first hook for the “my cat barely drinks” worry.
Write a pain-first hook for owners worried their cat drinks too little. Open with the worry in the owner's own words from these reviews, then pivot to what changed. Two sentences maximum, no fear-mongering, no medical claims. Reviews: [paste].10. Compare two headline sets and recommend one.
Here are two sets of Stillwell Pet headlines. Score each headline on clarity, specificity and how closely it echoes real reviews. Recommend the strongest three overall and say why in one line each. Sets: [paste].11. Cut the winning headline to a 15-word ad version.
Take this winning Stillwell Pet headline and write a 15-word version for a paid ad, plus a 6-word version for a thumbnail overlay. Keep the owner outcome and lose every adjective that adds nothing. Headline: [paste].Objection Handling and FAQ Copy
Two-star reviews are the cheapest research you will ever get. Use them before someone else does.
12. Turn the top complaints into objection handlers.
From these low-star Stillwell Pet reviews, list the top five objections. For each, write a two-sentence honest response that acknowledges it and states what is true. Do not dismiss the complaint or promise a fix we do not have. Reviews: [paste].13. Write the FAQ block for the noise question.
Write three FAQ entries for the Stillwell Pet fountain answering "is it noisy". Base the answer on what reviews say about pump sound at night. Keep each answer under 45 words and include one concrete detail, like decibels or a bedroom scenario. Reviews: [paste].14. Answer “my cat ignored it for a week”.
Write an FAQ answer for owners whose cat ignored the Stillwell Pet fountain at first. Explain the two-week adjustment that reviewers describe, give one practical tip from the reviews, and set a realistic expectation. Under 60 words. Reviews: [paste].15. Address filter cost and replacement cadence.
Write copy addressing the objection that replacement filters cost too much. Use real reviewer comments about filter life and cost per month. Be specific with numbers from the reviews and avoid vague reassurance. Under 70 words. Reviews: [paste].16. Handle the “it leaked on the floor” complaint.
Some Stillwell Pet reviewers report leaks. Write a fair objection handler: acknowledge the reports, explain the common cause reviewers found, and give the check that fixes it. Honest tone, no blame, under 70 words. Reviews: [paste].17. Compress every objection answer to 40 words.
Rewrite these objection answers to 40 words each without losing the specific detail. Cut hedging and repeated words. Keep the acknowledgment first and the reassurance second. Answers: [paste].Product Page Blocks and Bullets
Once the angles work, the page has to hold them. These blocks do the holding.
18. Five benefit bullets in the owners’ own vocabulary.
Write five benefit bullets for the Stillwell Pet fountain product page using the exact words owners use in these reviews, not marketing terms. Each bullet: one benefit, under 12 words, no hype. Reviews: [paste].19. The page intro paragraph above the buy button.
Write a 60-word product page intro for the Stillwell Pet fountain. Lead with the outcome reviewers describe most, add one proof point with a number from the reviews, and end with who it is for. Plain, specific, no exclamation marks. Reviews: [paste].20. The “what’s in the box” copy.
Write a clean what's-in-the-box list for the Stillwell Pet fountain: fountain unit, pump, filter, adapter, quick guide. Add one line per item describing what it does. Base any extra included items on what reviewers mention receiving. Under 90 words. Reviews: [paste].21. A comparison block against a plain bowl and a gravity feeder.
Write a three-row comparison for the Stillwell Pet fountain against a plain water bowl and a gravity feeder. Rows: fresh water, cat appeal, cleaning effort. Use points reviewers raised, keep each cell under 15 words, and stay factual. Reviews: [paste].22. Captions for the spec table.
Write one short caption for each spec figure for the Stillwell Pet fountain: capacity, filter life, power, dimensions. Each caption under 14 words and must explain why the number matters to a cat owner, not just state it. Specs: [paste].23. The care and cleaning section, minus the scare tactics.
Write a care and cleaning section for the Stillwell Pet fountain. Use the cleaning routine reviewers say actually works, how often they do it, and one thing that goes wrong if you skip it. Under 120 words, friendly and practical. Reviews: [paste].24. A trust block that cites the review count honestly.
Write a 40-word trust block for the Stillwell Pet page citing the review count and average rating: 1,800 reviews at 4.3 stars. Mention both the praise and that some owners report leaks, then link to reviews. No claim we cannot support. Data: [paste].Retention, Email and Review Requests
Reviews feed the next wave of copy. Close the loop so the flow keeps running.
25. The post-purchase welcome email.
Write a welcome email for a new Stillwell Pet fountain buyer. Set up the first seven days: placement, the two-week adjustment period, and the filter reminder. Under 130 words, one clear next step, no upselling in this email. Reviews: [paste].26. The filter refill reminder based on real filter life.
Write a filter refill reminder email for Stillwell Pet owners, timed to the filter life reviewers report. Include the cadence, a one-click reorder line, and one note about keeping the water fresh. Under 90 words, no guilt language. Reviews: [paste].27. A review request aimed at a happy buyer.
Write a review request email to a Stillwell Pet buyer whose fountain arrived two weeks ago. Ask one specific question about their cat's drinking habit rather than a generic request. Under 70 words, one link, easy to answer from a phone. Reviews: [paste].28. A win-back email for silent owners.
Write a win-back email for Stillwell Pet owners who have not reordered filters in three months. Reference the two problems reviewers say cause people to stop using the fountain, offer the fix, and keep it short. Under 90 words. Reviews: [paste].29. A public reply to a one-star review.
Write a public reply to a one-star Stillwell Pet review that complains the pump is loud. Thank them, take the issue seriously, state the concrete troubleshooting step, and invite a private message. Under 80 words, never argue. Review: [paste].30. A monthly insight note from the newest reviews.
From this month's new Stillwell Pet reviews, write a five-bullet note for the product team: what changed in sentiment, which theme is growing, and one quote worth reading. Quantify where you can and keep each bullet to one line. Reviews: [paste].Bonus: Turning 1,800 Reviews into a Copy Bank
Keep a quote file, not a summary file. Save the exact sentences; the phrasing is the asset. Never average away the outliers. One vivid two-star complaint teaches the page more than fifty identical five-stars. Refresh the five best quotes each month so the page ages with the product. Tag every quote with its star rating before you use it, so nobody quotes a complaint as praise. For keeping the resulting voice steady across pages, pair this with our brand voice comparison.
Sources & Notes
Prompts were tested with a GPT-4o class model through 2025 and are model-agnostic. Stillwell Pet, the 1,800 reviews and the 4.3-star average are fictional; use your own exported review text. Always check that a quoted line really exists in the source before it reaches a page, and drop any review claim about health, illness or medical outcomes, since a pet fountain is not a treatment and review copy cannot make a health claim.
